Are children from ‘broken’ homes more likely to be abused?
An article came out over the AP wire yesterday that has me sad and worried. Abuse Risk Seen Worse as Families Change, the article declares. ABC News has picked up the story, with a dramatic photo of a young, tatooed mother mourning at her small son’s grave.
I’m wondering, what is going on? Are single mothers so desperate for the companionship, financial support, and attention of a man that they are blinding themselves to their chosen partner’s shortcomings? From David Crary’s article, a frightening glimpse into what can happen when a woman makes the wrong choice, for whatever reasons:
“I’ve seen many cases of physical and sexual abuse that come up with boyfriends, stepparents,” said Eliana Gil, clinical director for the national abuse-prevention group Childhelp.
“It comes down to the fact they don’t have a relationship established with these kids,” she said. “Their primary interest is really the adult partner, and they may find themselves more irritated when there’s a problem with the children.”
That was the case with Jayden Cangro.
In July 2006, his mother’s boyfriend, Phillip Guymon, hurled the 2-year-old nine feet across a room in Murray, Utah, because he balked at going to bed. The child died from his injuries.
Jayden’s mother, Carly Moore, has undergone therapy since the killing. Yet she continues to second-guess herself about her two-year relationship with Guymon.
“There’s so much guilt,” she said in a telephone interview. “I never saw him hit my kids, ever. But he was gruff in his manner — there were signs that he wasn’t most pleasant person for kids to be around.”
I’m not pointing fingers at this woman. God knows, she’s got enough to deal with, and I’m not going to condemn her. Her boyfriend threw her child across the room.
But please, single mothers everywhere, please. Listen to yourself. If there is something about the situation you are in that makes you uncomfortable, then extracate yourself as quickly as possible. Don’t wait for grave harm to come to you or your children before you try to save yourselves. I mean, come on. There’s a reason we’re single parents, isn’t there? Either our original partners were not right for us, or we knew that the atmosphere in the house with our children’s birth father wasn’t healthy… so we got divorced… or we never married the baby’s father in the first place because we knew the relationship wasn’t a good thing for a child… or we lost that loving father to death and have to pick up the pieces… or we chose to have a child independent of a father’s involvement because we never met Mr. Right and weren’t going to settle for Mr. Good Enough…
Do any of these scenarios sound familiar? As a single parent, we should be constantly, but not obsessively, checking our inner yardstick to be sure we are not repeating any painful mistakes and lessons of our past. Until you, as a woman, a human being, and a mother, are strong enough, vibrant and confident enough in yourself; until you know the true value of your own self, and can measure your self-worth in healthy decisions, careful choices, and a better life for you and your children; please, don’t shack up with that guy. Please don’t settle for someone who eases your loneliness at the expense of your safety.
Being a single parent is hard. It’s exhausting. It’s demanding. It’s never-ending. You don’t have anyone you can hand off the annoying kid to, or snuggle up to in the middle of the night and share your worries about Jr. with. It’s just you. Until you’re strong enough to handle just you, don’t bring someone else into your life.
And when you do think you’ve found the right partner in your life, please go to marriage and family counseling together. Blending families is hard work. Do the hard work before you say “I do”, or sign the lease together, or whatever constitutes a commitment to this new person in your lives.
Tags: Abuse-Risk-Seen-Worse-as-Families-Change, AP, blending-families, David-Crary, step-family, step-father, step-mother
5 opinions for Are children from ‘broken’ homes more likely to be abused?
ratphooey
Nov 18, 2007 at 10:31 pm
“Are single mothers so desperate for the companionship, financial support, and attention of a man that they are blinding themselves to their chosen partner’s shortcomings?”
Yes. At least, some are. Some women, period, are, even those without children. What kind of less-than-zero self esteem must it take to stay in a relationship like that. It makes my heart ache just to think of it.
christina
Nov 18, 2007 at 11:20 pm
I can’t stand it. It just… boggles the mind. I mean, I’ll take a lot of abuse, but when I see my child is being treated shabbily, I’m up in arms. To know in your gut that the man you’re sleeping with isn’t nice to your kid? It sucks. And you have to listen to that gut.
Jenny
Nov 19, 2007 at 12:43 am
Hmmm…has anyone read the linked article? I mean, really read it?
Yes, it’s tragic that some single mothers are damaged to the point they can’t see how much of a loser their man is. But I think what’s just as tragic is when media use these stories to scare everyone into believing that single parenthood is a problem that the government needs to fix. Like I need more right wing fundamentalists in my business.
We all know there’s a risk of abuse to all kids, whether their parents are married or not, regardless of economic level. The only way to keep a kid truly safe from abuse of any kind is to not have any. So, let’s try not to be distracted by the stats. Instead, let’s be concerned about our government sticking its faith-based nose where it most definitely does not belong.
christina
Nov 19, 2007 at 12:58 am
Oh, Jennifer. I read the whole article, the AP article and the ABC piece. Yes i’m sickened by what the media does to facts like these. I’m tired of the spin. But there’s a fundamental problem with people who attach themselves to the wrong partner for fear of being alone… and that’s what is at the heart of this phenomenon. My whole point is that women should try to heal themselves before they get caught up in another nasty, destructive relationship.
I don’t think I need fixing by the gummn’t. I think the gummn’t needs fixin’. I’m just going to make sure my chad isn’t hanging, pregnant, or otherwise subject to hijacking by those folks in the White House, next year.
ratphooey
Nov 19, 2007 at 9:18 am
Jenny, it’s not the media per se that manipulates things. It’s the right wingers who try to spin data for their own ends. Not that there aren’t some media outlets with a clear political agenda (I’m looking at you, Fox “News”).
They fail in this case, because of course many more children are abused by their own parent/s than by a single parent’s SO.
And the fact that information can be manipulated by parties with an agenda doesn’t invalidate the information altogether.
Have an opinion? Leave a comment: